Chef Paolino Cafe

Nestled in the heart of Catonsville, MD, Chef Paolino Cafe offers a vibrant taste of authentic Italian cuisine with a special spotlight on genuine New York-style pizza. This cozy yet lively eatery invites guests to indulge in a comforting, casually elegant dining experience where every dish bursts with rich, savory flavors and heartfelt culinary craftsmanship.

The menu is an enticing journey through classic Italian favorites and inventive specialties. Pizza lovers will delight in generous, meat-stacked options such as the Meat Lovers Pizza and crowd-pleasers like the Large Pepperoni Pizza and Cheese Pepperoni Italian Sausage Pizza, all served with a perfectly balanced crust that strikes a satisfying harmony between crispy and chewy. Compliment your pie with sides like the famous Garlic Knots smothered in garlic butter and served with a zesty tomato sauce or the crispy Old Bay Wings, which are packed with a tantalizingly bold flavor.

Not just a pizza spot, Chef Paolino Cafe’s pasta options burst with homey indulgence—think Spaghetti Puttanesca, rich with Italian olives, capers, and anchovies in a robust marinara, and the creamy, luxurious Chicken Alfredo Crispy Chicken. For lunchtime favorites, you can’t miss the Chicken Marsala, where tender chicken breast sautés with mushrooms in a velvety marsala wine sauce over spaghetti, creating a dish that’s both comforting and refined. The Chicken Parmigiana, topped with melted mozzarella and rich tomato sauce, echoes the nostalgic flavors of Italy with every bite.

The dining atmosphere is inviting and relaxed, with a casual counter-ordering system that ensures swift service without losing that warm, personal touch. Customers mention the easy-going vibe paired with attentive, friendly staff who are always ready with a smile and accommodating spirit. Parking is hassle-free thanks to a spacious lot right in front, making every visit effortless.

Vegetable sides like sautéed broccoli or spinach, and extras such as Side of Grilled Salmon or Blackened Chicken, provide a welcome balance to the hearty mains. Don’t overlook the tempting dessert offerings like the creamy, smooth Vanilla Cheesecake, perfect for rounding out a satisfying meal.

Chef Paolino Cafe also impresses with its beverage selection, offering popular classic cocktails for takeout including the Espresso Martini, Margarita, and Manhattan, each skillfully crafted to elevate your dining experience at home or on the go.

What truly stands out from customer testimonials is the authentic, New York-style pizza experience that satisfies even the most discerning pizza snobs. Joseph Bullen praises the generous toppings on the Meat Lover’s Pizza and the delicious garlic knots, while Jessica Jacobi shares how her New York-raised husband has made this his favorite local spot. William McIntyre appreciates the generous portions, friendly service, and reasonable prices, highlighting the perfectly crafted Meatball Sub and Eggplant Parmigiana. Moreover, the positive reviews for delivery from “NY” emphasize not only the quality and freshness of the Chicken Marsala but also the thoughtful inclusion of gluten-free options that taste indistinguishably delicious.

Whether you're craving the soulful comfort of Italian classics or a perfectly executed slice of pizza loaded with quality toppings, Chef Paolino Cafe delivers a memorable dining experience with genuine warmth and flavor that keeps patrons coming back. It’s a place where the comfort of traditional recipes meets the convenience and friendliness of neighborhood dining—truly a gem in Catonsville’s culinary scene.

Chef Paolino Cafe
726 Frederick Rd, Catonsville, MD 21228
Phone: +1 410-747-4949